Thanksgiving Pie List: Printable Checklist
A Thanksgiving pie list should cover pie flavors such as pumpkin, pecan and apple, crusts or ready-made shells, fillings and spices, baking tools, whipped cream or ice cream, and a plan to bake ahead, cool, store and slice each pie.
First checklist's on us. Drop your email and we'll send a one-time code, good for any checklist in the catalog.
One free checklist per person. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
What should be on a thanksgiving pie list?
A Thanksgiving pie list should cover pie flavors such as pumpkin, pecan and apple, crusts or ready-made shells, fillings and spices, baking tools, whipped cream or ice cream, and a plan to bake ahead, cool, store and slice each pie.
This printable thanksgiving pie list has 24 items in 4 sections, and you can tick them off on your phone or print the 2-page PDF.
The full thanksgiving pie list
Pie Flavors
- Pumpkin pie
- Pecan pie
- Apple pie
- Sweet potato pie
- Cream or fruit option
Crust + Filling
- Pie crusts or shells
- Canned or fresh pumpkin
- Eggs and cream
- Spices and sugar
- Pecans or apples
Baking Tools
- Pie dishes
- Pie crust shield
- Pastry blender
- Rolling pin
- Cooling racks
Serve
- Whipped cream
- Vanilla ice cream
- Pie server
- Dessert plates
- Storage wrap or pie carrier
Often forgotten
- Parchment paper
- Extra butter
- Pie weights
- Foil for covering
Thanksgiving Pie List tips
- Count slices: plan 1 slice per guest, plus a few spares.
- Chill the dough: cold dough rolls out more easily.
- Mix pie styles: one fruit, one custard and one nut pie covers most tastes.
- Label allergens: nut pies need a clear sign.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Baking everything the same day. Bake pies a day ahead and store them properly.
- Leaving custard pies out. Pumpkin and other egg-based pies should be refrigerated.
- Skipping the crust shield. A shield stops the edge from over-browning.
Why trust this checklist
Built from FDA holiday food safety, USDA food safety and FDA food allergy information.
Who this checklist is for
Hosts planning dessert, guests bringing a pie and anyone baking for a crowd.
What you get
- A 2-page printable PDF (US Letter)
- An interactive version you can tick off on a phone, tablet or computer
- A gear kit page with our recommended picks
- Instant download after checkout
Thanksgiving Pie List FAQ
What pies are traditional for Thanksgiving?
Pumpkin, pecan and apple are the most common, with sweet potato pie popular in many families.
How many pies do I need?
Plan for about 1 slice per guest, which is roughly 1 pie for every 8 people, plus extra if you want seconds.
Do pumpkin pies need to be refrigerated?
Yes. Pumpkin pie is egg-based, so refrigerate it after it cools and do not leave it out for long.
Can I bake pies ahead of time?
Yes. Bake a day ahead and refrigerate any custard pies, or freeze unbaked pies if you want to prep further out.
Is this thanksgiving pie list printable?
Yes. It is a two-page printable PDF that also works on your phone.
Related checklists: Thanksgiving Grocery List, Thanksgiving Hosting Checklist, Thanksgiving Potluck Checklist, Thanksgiving Leftovers Checklist
Read the full guide: Thanksgiving Pies: How Many to Make, Which Kinds, and How to Bake Ahead
Reviews
Common questions
How do I get my checklist after buying?
You'll get an instant download link in your order confirmation email, plus access to the interactive version if you're a subscriber.
Does this work on my phone?
Yes. Every checklist is built mobile responsive, with clickable checkboxes that work in any browser.
Can I print it?
Yes, every checklist includes a clean printable version alongside the interactive one.