Thanksgiving Pies: How Many to Make, Which Kinds, and How to Bake Ahead

thanksgiving pies - printable checklist guide from checklistsfor.com

Disclosure: Some links in this post are Amazon affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, Checklistsfor earns from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Thanksgiving pies are easier when you decide the flavors and count before you buy a single can of pumpkin. This Thanksgiving pies guide covers how many pies to make for your crowd, classic flavors to choose from, what you can bake ahead, how to store pies safely, and how to move them to someone else's house. Plan your Thanksgiving pies early so oven space goes to the turkey on the day.

Quick answer: For Thanksgiving pies, plan about one pie for every six to eight guests, plus one extra if you want leftovers. Choose two or three classics, like pumpkin, apple, and pecan, bake fruit and nut pies a day or two ahead, and keep custard pies like pumpkin refrigerated once cooled so dessert is ready without crowding the oven.

Key takeaways

  • Plan about one pie per six to eight guests.
  • Pick two or three flavors so there is a choice without extra work.
  • Make crusts early and freeze them, or buy good ready-made crusts.
  • Bake pies a day or two ahead so the oven is free for the turkey.
  • Refrigerate pumpkin and other custard pies once cooled.

How many Thanksgiving pies should you make?

A standard pie cuts into about eight slices, so one pie per six to eight guests is a safe count. Add one more if you want leftovers or if guests usually try two kinds.

  • Count adults and kids who will be at dessert
  • Divide by six to eight for the basic pie count
  • Add one pie if you want leftovers to send home
  • Ask guests if anyone is bringing dessert so you do not overbake
  • Plan one smaller or alternate pie for allergies or diets
  • Note the final count and flavors before you shop

Write flavors, counts, and ingredients on the printable Thanksgiving Pie List.

What are the most popular Thanksgiving pies?

Pumpkin, apple, and pecan are the classic Thanksgiving pies. Sweet potato, cherry, and chocolate cream are common additions for a bigger table.

  • Pumpkin pie with a spiced custard filling
  • Apple pie with a lattice or double crust
  • Pecan pie, rich and easy to make ahead
  • Sweet potato pie, a Southern favorite
  • Cherry or mixed berry pie for a fruit option
  • Chocolate cream or French silk for chocolate fans

How far ahead can you bake Thanksgiving pies?

Fruit and pecan pies can be baked one to two days ahead. Pumpkin and other custard pies are best made a day ahead and refrigerated once they cool.

  1. Make and freeze pie dough a week or more ahead
  2. Shop pie ingredients with the main Thanksgiving grocery run
  3. Bake pecan and fruit pies one to two days before Thanksgiving
  4. Bake pumpkin or custard pies the day before
  5. Cool pies fully on a rack before covering
  6. Refrigerate custard and cream pies; cover fruit pies loosely

Work through the Thanksgiving Pie Baking Prep Checklist. A 9-inch glass pie dish lets you check the bottom crust for browning.

How do you store Thanksgiving pies?

Custard pies like pumpkin and sweet potato go in the refrigerator once they cool. Fruit and pecan pies can sit covered at room temperature for a day or two, then move to the fridge.

  • Let pies cool completely before covering
  • Refrigerate pumpkin, sweet potato, and cream pies
  • Cover fruit pies loosely with foil to keep the crust crisp
  • Keep pies away from strong-smelling foods in the fridge
  • Bring chilled pies out a little before serving if you like them less cold
  • Refrigerate leftovers and use them within a few days

How do you transport Thanksgiving pies?

Move pies fully cooled, in a carrier or box, on a flat surface in the car. Bring toppings like whipped cream separately and add them at the table.

  • Cool pies completely so the filling sets
  • Use a pie carrier or a sturdy box with a towel underneath
  • Set pies flat on the car floor or a level trunk
  • Pack custard pies in a cooler if the drive is long
  • Bring whipped cream, a pie server, and a knife
  • Label the pie flavor and any allergens for the host

Follow the Thanksgiving Pie Transport Checklist and set up dessert with the Thanksgiving Dessert Buffet Checklist. A pie carrier with a lid keeps the top intact.

What Thanksgiving pies tips get better results?

  • Blind bake the crust for pumpkin and custard pies to avoid a soggy bottom.
  • Shield crust edges with foil or a pie shield once they are golden.
  • Pumpkin pie is set when the edges are firm and the center jiggles slightly.
  • Chill dough before rolling so it is easier to handle.
  • Put a sheet pan under fruit pies to catch drips.
  • Ask for guests' favorite flavor so the pie they want is on the table.

Related checklists

Thanksgiving pies FAQ

How many pies do I need for Thanksgiving?

Plan about one pie for every six to eight guests, plus one if you want leftovers.

Can I make pumpkin pie two days ahead?

Pumpkin pie is best made a day ahead and kept in the refrigerator once cooled.

Does pumpkin pie need to be refrigerated?

Yes. Pumpkin pie is a custard pie, so refrigerate it once it cools.

Can I freeze Thanksgiving pies?

Fruit and pecan pies freeze well. Custard and cream pies can get watery, so bake those closer to the day.

What is the most popular Thanksgiving pie?

Pumpkin pie is the classic, followed closely by apple and pecan.

Should I bake pies on Thanksgiving Day?

Bake them a day or two ahead when you can, so the oven is free for the turkey and sides.

Print it, set your pie count, and bake ahead so the oven is free on Thanksgiving. Get the Thanksgiving Pie List (printable + interactive).